the key in understanding this is in the antithesis of her conditions. The character Bianca Minola in William Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew appears to be a perfect opposite to her older sister Katherina/Kate, the shrew of the play's title. While in this society, a woman is asked to be obedient, it is not without men serving women as well. Petruchio began his famous process of taming his bride. A really great hub about a fantastic play, one i would dearly love to see in London on stage some day, thanks for sharing, voted up, Lee. Shakespearean Criticism. Shakespeare, William. Shakespeare hat das Werk vermutlich spätestens im … This is why Petruchio’s form of violence was accepted; because he was the master of his property and could do what he wanted with it. Sly is carried to the Lord's bedchamber and decked in lavish attire. Taming of the Shrew begins with a group of hunting nobleman tricking a drunken tinker named Christopher Sly into believing he is a lord. The subtextual message in the speech is directed to Petruchio and Kate clearly outlines the obligations and rewards he is entitled to if he acts properly. Petruchio’s goal with Kate is to tame her. She seems to find him exciting and enjoys the way that he challenges her. Kristen Howe from Northeast Ohio on June 22, 2015: Angela, nice review on that classic Shakespearan play. Whether you see the relationships in the play as harmlessly boisterous and knockabout or tragically violent and oppressive, Shakespeare is clearly offering us his take on that perennial trope in both comedy and tragedy : the … She did not, which shows Petruchio’s effect on her. Most of Treasure Island features a first person narrator, Jim Hawkins. Many scholars feel that, despite Kate’s submissiveness in the closing scene of the play, she would continue to be a strong opposition for Petruchio. The Taming of the Shrew Widely reputed throughout Padua to be a shrew, Katherine is foul-tempered and sharp-tongued at the start of the play. Sly wants to be left alone with his wife, but the servants tell him that a troupe of actors has arrived to present a play for him. Analysing Petruchio's Language Petruchio has 22 per cent of the lines in the play, and is a catalyst for the main events. A Lord passing by notices Sly and decides to play a trick on him. icon-close Petruchio’s words left no doubt as to his belief in the patriarchal marriage system that existed during Shakespeare’s time, perhaps presented in somewhat of an exaggerated form (Kahn 414). She responds with, “But no sir, God forbid, but ashamed to kiss” (V.ii.137), which signifies more the feelings towards public displays of affection during this time rather than her feelings of kissing Petruchio. Angela is an avid reader who studied English Literature in college. Answer: Keep in mind that Petruchio wanted to marry a wealthy woman. Although Act IV, Scene 5 is the shortest scene of the play, it is clearly the most important one so far. From the beginning, Petruchio wanted to dominate a relationship of two dominating personalities. This Shakespeare play is not often touted as a favorite. Petruchio’s method of “taming” Kate featured depriving her of the things she had taken for granted and been given all of her life, and he sarcastically acted as if it was in her best interest (Leggatt 410). I personally believe that yes, we should definitely study this play as it helps give insight into the past. In the introduction, an impish nobleman beguiles a drunken man Christopher Sly to believe that he is a nobleman. Charles Robert Leslie (1794–1859), via Wikimedia Commons. Untitled Essay. The Taming of the Shrew is one of the earliest comedies written by sixteenth and seventeenth century English bard, William Shakespeare. It is not Gremio or any other suitor that Kate feels jealousy towards; she feels jealous of Bianca and how everyone, even their father, views her as the preferred sister. 1106- 1107. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1960. For the first time in Kate’s life, she sees others being verbally abused by someone other than herself, as Petruchio presents himself as an even worse shrew than herself. Another point in the play where Kate displayed her complaisance was when she came at Petruchio’s call. Though it is Petruchio who helped her along the journey, if she hadn't desired for love, in the beginning, her transformation would not have occurred. She is a strong person, which attracts Petruchio. Her speech at the end is over the top and is often thought to be mocking and sarcastic. Another instant when Kate obeyed her husband’s outlandish demands came as somewhat of a surprise after the wager scene. If she were utterly broken of spirit, she would have simply agreed without an elaborate speech. That answer probably will not be in any textbook on the Taming of the Shrew, but that is my own personal opinion. Kate’s violence was very unacceptable in their society, because women just did not do that at that time. This speech addresses his absurdity by saying, “But sun it is not when you say it is not, / And the moon changes even as your mind” (V.i.20-21). It is supposed to be written between 1590 and 1592. Personally, I believe that the husband and wife have a symbiotic relationship. Petruchio displayed complete trust in Kate in that situation, and she came through for her man. Congrats your Hub of the Day award for an interesting post filled with food for thought. Science Teacher and Lover of Essays. Her groom, Petruchio, has nearly as much mystery surrounding him as does Kate herself. Then again, in her final speech, Kate talks at length with a strong presence that captivates her audience, further proving she is still the feisty woman she had been at the very beginning but with new understanding. If she had meant it to be sarcastic, this admission of being cared for would seem out of place and misguided. Ed. The fact that she is willing to go along with his outlandish remarks and humiliate a man she has never met proves she has not lost her spunk. With her new understanding, Kate’s actions and words begin to change, but not her personality. Rather, her final speech is a hostile negotiation in which failure to agree results in a loss of face, reputation and money on Petruchio's part. The play begins with a framing device, often referred to as the induction, in which a mischievous nobleman tricks a drunken tinker named Christopher Sly into believing he is actually a nobleman himself. I think if a man is truly loving his wife as Jesus loved the church, then her best interest would always be in the forefront of his mind; therefore, he would not just expect her to serve him solely, but take care of herself as well. Analysis. In a sense, Kate and Petruchio had what one might call a symbiotic relationship; that is, they both had a strong need for each other, which is somewhat paradoxical, as both of them were fiercely independent characters. Logan, IA: The Perfection Form Company, 1986. Here we meet Christopher Sly, a tinker by trade and a drunk by avocation. It has lasted many years, and is still as great as the original. However, Ruth Nevo pointed out that Kate did not only win the wager, but her speech testifies a generosity worth far more than the two hundred crowns of the wager (264). Shakespearean Criticism. Here we see Kate coming to understand that, when she agrees to let Petruchio have his way, she reaps the benefits. Many critics have pointed out that the wager scene is dominated by reversals: quiet Bianca talked back, while the shrewish Katherina came across as an obedient wife (Kahn 418). A Streetcar Named Desire A Tale of Two Cities Lord of the Flies The Taming of the Shrew The Tempest The play opens with a device referred to as an introduction. Marriage ceremonies generally mark the end of Shakespearean comedy — but in this case the ceremony is only the beginning! Das Werk spielt in der italienischen Stadt Padua und handelt von dem reichen Kaufmann Baptista und den Umständen der Heirat seiner beiden Töchter Bianca und Katharina. The Taming of the Shrew) ist eine Komödie von William Shakespeare. The noblemen give Sly a disguised young page as his supposed wife. Question: Should we still study and celebrate this play? HIRE verified writer $35.80 for a 2-page paper. They have really similar characters names and their behaviours. Having trouble understanding The Taming of the Shrew? A turning point in her selfishness occurs when the servants bring out the “burnt” meat (IV.i.151). Does The Taming of the Shrew advocate sexual inequality or does it show and critique men’s attempts to subordinate women? Instead, she plays the game with Petruchio by calling the man a “young budding virgin, fair and fresh and sweet” (V.i.36). When she refuses the first time, he asks if it’s because she is embarrassed of him. Though she evolves in her ideas and actions, her personality is essentially the same as it is in the beginning but shaped by empathy and love. She especially enjoyed admonishing Bianca for her unseemly behavior (Dash 835). His sincerity is in question because he plans to “woo her with some spirit when she comes” (II.i.170) and praise her with the opposite of her actions. Adapting the Shrew. Metaphor Analysis Point of View Point of view refers to the character through whom the story is told. Because of this, she seeks it through childish means such as petty questions and fighting. The shrewish Kate, who was known to have a sharp tongue, very adequately filled his need for another powerful character in a relationship (Kahn 419). It is thought by many to be one of Shakespeare’s most immature plays (Cyclopedia 1106). The play Taming of the Shrew by William Shakespeare, written in 1590-1592, takes place in Italy. This is really well-written. Kate was presented to be much more intelligent and witty than Bianca, but, ironically, she could not compete with Bianca because of these witty comebacks and caustic remarks she made (Dash 830). Ed. 825-833. Angela Michelle Schultz (author) from United States on March 07, 2010: I am careful to use the word submit, because there is a duality that is going on. As if all of these symbols of her obedience were not enough, Kate showed one more sign. This is Baptista's way of ensuring that someone… read analysis of Baptista Minola. The real difference between the Kate that Gremio refers to as a “fiend of hell” (I.i.89), to the Kate that Baptista gives “another dowry to” (V.ii.120), is that she has learned to look beyond herself and begins to express love. In contrast, Kate does not believe that he feels the same way towards her. Because of the helplessness of her situation, she began to show submission to her husband. In fact, Katharina seems quite angered by the situation. Petruchio, Katherine, Hortensio, and some of Petruchio's servants are making the journey from Petruchio's house to Padua. Katherine Minola is a fiery, spirited woman, and as such, the male dominated world around her doesn't quite know what to do with her. Another point that must be made concerning her speech is that she delighted in reprimanding the other ladies for their unconventional behavior. A detailed analysis of gender roles, the main theme of Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew, as well as other motifs such as appearance vs. reality and animal imagery. It is supposed to be written between 1590 and 1592. This refers to what men of this time had to do for their wives. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of every Shakespeare play. Here's an in-depth analysis of the most important parts, in an easy-to-understand format. Analysis. Thelma Alberts from Germany and Philippines on June 22, 2015: Very well reviewed. Kate’s response was that it changes even as his mind, and this was the first sign of her submission to Petruchio (Evans 32). This willingness to step outside of herself to defend someone else reflects her ability to empathize. Regardless, this is the first time she hears such flatteries as being called as “sweet as springtime flowers” (II.i.247) or being told “thy beauty that doth make me like thee well” (II.i.275) then eventually requesting her hand in marriage. The patriarchal styles that the marriages took on during the Elizabethan age are very well represented in Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew. The marriages of the time were very male dominated. She uses the expression “God forbid,” which emphasizes her feelings against being ashamed of him. Analysis and discussion of characters in William Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for our End-of-Year sale—Join Now! Taming of the Shrew Essay May 31, 2014. This showed how Kate was actually a foil of Petruchio (Nevo 262). Despite Kate’s apparent anti-feminist talk, Kate has not become a completely broken, weak-willed woman. It is a good example that we have to open ourselves up, deal with the bitterness and gradually accept who we are. Question: How did Bianca become the shrew at the end of Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew"? These provided the comical aspect of the play, as well as giving Kate a chance to look at her own image (Nevo 262). Zorba the Geek, via Wikimedia Commons Taming of the Shrew Essay In The Taming of the Shrew, Kate goes through a fantastic transformation from a harsh spitfire to a spirited yet submissive wife. The whole plot of the play drives toward these goals. If he is dishonest, then her rebellion becomes patriotic since the contract has become essentially null and void. While preparing himself for Katharina's entrance, Petruchio proclaims his intention to believe the opposite of whatever Kate tries to say about herself: "Say that she rail, why then I'll tell her plain/She sings as sweetly as a nightingale." I believe both Kate and Petruchio are putting on an act towards the end, but I do believe that they both know that the other is acting and they are doing so out of mutual respect. The book is a comedy, mainly about Petruchio and his wife Kate. I think I know what you are trying to get at. Scott, Mark W. and Williamson, Sandra L., et al., ed. Few women, now and especially during Shakespeare’s time, would be willing to risk humiliation for themselves or others, unless they have a strong personality. Let us do your homework! The play that Sly watches makes up the main story of The Taming of the Shrew. When the tailor brought in what seemed to be a very pretty cap, Petruchio refused to let Kate have it, despite her incessant pleas to keep the cap (Legatt 410). Even Jesus allowed suffering on himself in order to save his church. Here we meet Christopher Sly, a tinker by trade and a drunk by avocation. Taming of the Shrew by William Shakespeare and the modern film 10 Thingss I hate about you are analogous to each other in many ways. Despite his flattery, she still seeks to find love from him, although she seeks it in juvenile ways. In the name of love, Petruchio refused to let her eat, under the pretense that she deserved better food than what was being given her (Nevo 262). Ed. To help you look at any scene in The Taming of The Shrew and begin to analyse it, it’s important to ask questions about how it's written and why. As she describes a husband to Bianca and the widow, she states, “thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper, / thy head thy sovereign, one that cares for thee” (V.ii.153). This question is much like what a child would ask their mother or best friend. The Taming of the Shrew is a comedy play written by William Shakespeare. This transformation is due to Petruchio’s over-the-top kindness towards Kate and cruelty towards all others. Some scholars believe it may have been his first work written for the stage as well as his first comedy (Shakespearean 310). Answer: It is debatable whether she truly allows herself to be tamed. That being said, humans love to watch Home Alone and laugh at the cruel treatment of the two thieves, so it was intended to bring humor by being way over the top. Petruchio playfully hints that since she won’t kiss him in public, they should go home. Through her word choices, one can see that she has indeed fallen in love with Petruchio. This affectionate term further signifies that she has fallen in love with Petruchio. Due to his harsh words towards the servants, Kate tries to reason with him by stating, “I pray you, ‘tis a fault unwilling” (IV.i.153). The Taming of the Shrew essays are academic essays for citation. In Act III, Scene 2, roughly the play's mid-point, Shakespeare gives us one of the most unusual (and unpleasant) weddings in literary history. Answer: I personally believe that Petruchio is unkind and disrespectful. “‘Kate of Kate Hall’: The Taming of the Shrew.” Modern Critical Reviews. A very good critical study. The Taming of the Shrew: Stand by Your Man - The Psychotherapist Perspective The universal nature of the themes in The Taming of the Shrew, beg analysis and social critique. Petruchio believes that women should do what their men say. One example of this new love being for Petruchio is when Kate first arrives at her father’s home. She is talking amongst both men and women, yet all listen. Analysis. He sought to tame her in a nonviolent but still somewhat cruel fashion. Only someone who could demand such authority would have been able to give such a robust lengthy speech. This remedy appealed to the intelligent aspect of Kate’s complex personality, and they brought about a change in her. Because she is stubborn, is sometimes ill-mannered, and does not allow herself to be ordered around by men, she is constantly insulted, made fun of, and otherwise denigrated by practically all the other characters in the play. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of The Taming of the Shrew by William Shakespeare. Voted up for useful! Petruchio is one of two central characters (along with Katherine) in Shakespeare’s play, The Taming of the Shrew.. Petruchio is a wealthy young bachelor looking for an equally rich wife. Dive deep into William Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew with extended analysis, commentary, and discussion perfect for college-level preparation The Taming of the Shrew is a comic play written by William Shakespeare around 1590 and first published in 1898. Petruchio’s actions were very extreme during the play, but as Kate caught on to their role playing their relationship improved (Nevo 262). Some scholars believe it may have been his first work written for the stage as well as his first comedy (Shakespearean 310). It was written between 1593 and 1594 and it is one of Shakespeare’s earliest comedies. One of the best scenes to reflect this would be before Kate’s arrival at her father’s house as Petruchio and her are on their walk. As tiredness, hunger, and frustration set in on Kate, her wildcat personality began to weaken noticeably. Katherine Minola is a fiery, spirited woman, and as such, the male dominated world around her doesn't quite know what to do with her. This exchange of roles, which landed Kate on the receiving end of all of those hideous tantrums, took her out of herself. Petruchio beckons a kiss. Need help with Act 4, Scene 1 in William Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew? Answer: Any answer to this would be someone's opinion and therefore is up for debate. In The Taming of the Shrew, Kate goes through a fantastic transformation from a harsh spitfire to a spirited yet submissive wife. She once again complied in front of the surprised crowd. There are hints that the marriage of Petruchio and Kate may not have exactly met these standards, but for acceptance they attempted to make it look that way. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Character Analysis The main character in the play Taming of the Shrew is Katherine, who undergoes a major transformation throughout the play as she begins stubborn and ill tempered and ends a subservient wife. Kate still is able and willing to fight, which is apparent in her monologue.